VIEWPOINT: Brushfire Below Via de las Olas Was Most Likely Started by Transient

Quick action by firefighters, on the steep slopes, kept the fire from spreading and jumping to homes along the Via de las Olas bluffs.

The versatile “duck test” goes, “If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.”

The hillside brushfire on May 24 that burned two acres below Via de las Olas in late afternoon was most likely started by a transient—if we apply the duck test.

The L.A. Fire Department is not allowed to speculate about the origins of a fire, and unless a person is arrested for the fire, the cause remains a big mystery and, who knows? Maybe it was a welding accident or spontaneous combustion or just really bad luck or somebody threw a cigarette butt 500 feet from PCH into the brush.

Someone reported a man leaving the area with a black backpack immediately after the fire was spotted. But all the LAFD can say is “It’s under investigation.”

On the Friday before, your Circling the News editor was walking down Temescal Canyon towards PCH, and a “disturbed” transient who was muttering and smoking began following me. Stepping aside, I called the Pacific Palisades Task Force on Homelessness and alerted them that the guy appeared to be going above the picnic area into the bluffs.

Additionally, over the previous few weeks, two abandoned encampments had been cleaned by the PPTFH in the posted restricted fire areas along Temescal near PCH.

Most residents have noticed an uptick in transients who appear to have mental or meth/alcohol issues. When people are moved from encampments around the City, they are offered housing. Those who do not accept are asked to move on – and they do. Many of them take the free metro to areas such as Santa Monica and Pacific Palisades.

CTN has been told that lately  we have had some of the “worst of the worst” in our area: people who are too mentally ill to know they desperately need help.

CTN spoke to LAPD Officer John “Rusty” Redican after the Via de las Olas fire and he told me that he knows the exact location the fire started because he has cleared encampments at that location.

Pacific Palisades residents were fortunate that the fire department responded so quickly. Residents along the bluffs were also were lucky there was no wind, because the fire came dangerously close to their homes. It burned part of the fence that rims the canyon and is directly across the street from homes and towering eucalyptus trees.

That means that in the space of two weeks, residents have lucked out. First, the Palisades Fire that burned above the Highlands, which was also set by a transient (he was arrested, so we can say transient), didn’t spread like it would have had there been Santa Ana winds.

The Via de las Olas fire was reported immediately because people could see the smoke and flames from PCH—if it had been late at night or had there been winds … .the outcome would have been much different.

Pacific Palisades is surrounded and intersected by brush-covered canyons and hillsides, to that extent that the whole town is considered in a Very High Fire Severity Zone.

This year, instead of the normal 13.45 inches of rain (measured at the end of June), the total is only 4.26 inches—which means the mountains around us are tinder dry.

Officials ask residents to prepare for brushfires by 1) doing brush clearance, 2) getting your “to-go” bags ready and 3) if asked to evacuate, go.

Here’s a commonsense piece of advice that might make even more of a difference: Let’s keep the hillsides clear of those who might start a fire — either intentionally or unintentionally.

Sooner or later, our town’s luck will run out.

The fire burned to the edge of the road, including the bougainvillea on the fence. It was stopped before it spread to the homes across the street and the towering eucalyptus trees.

Posted in General | 2 Comments

Auditions for ‘Aladdin’ Set: Theatre Palisades Youth Summer Program

The popular Theatre Palisades Youth Summer Program will feature Disney’s “Aladdin.”

Youth in grades third through eighth (9 to 14 year olds) may participate by sending a video audition. The youth should sing a one-minute selection from any Broadway or Disney musical and perform any scene from “Aladdin”. (Parents can email director Lara Gantz for a copy of a script calrayganz@gmail.com). The video audition should be send no later than Wednesday, June 2.

“If a child doesn’t feel comfortable with singing just yet, please have them send in only the scene,” Gantz said. “We understand the process can be intimidating.”

Rehearsals for the show will be held in Temescal Gateway Park on the hillside known as “classroom row.” There’s a large outdoor space, an indoor classroom and restrooms throughout the month of July. The area has shade and is well separated from hikers and the Park.

Rehearsals and performances will take place from July 5 to July 31, Monday through Friday, 10 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. (an extended day option is available.)

Performance weekends are July 23-25 and July 30 and 31. An additional performance on August 1 may be an option, depending on cast availability.

Gantz told Circling the News in a May 30 email “This show is dedicated to Molly Steinsapir. Her brother, Nate, will be in the cast.

“Last summer, we had planned to do Aladdin before the pandemic shut us down,” Gantz said. “Molly had a script of Aladdin and shared it with me in order to try to persuade me to choose Aladdin for the summer 2020 show.”

Covid-19 shutdowns prevented performances last year, and then tragic bicycle accident took Steinsapir’s life on February 16.

Molly Steinspair (center)

Posted in Kids/Parenting, Schools | Leave a comment

Runners Can Still Make a Difference

Brian Shea, who helped found the Will Rogers 5/10K race, and who has served as a the race director sent out a plea to runners this year.

(Brian Shea, Will Rogers 5/10K Race Founder and Director of 44 years, sent the letter below. Many entrants might not realize that their entrance fee for the July 4 race not only pays for permits, timing and T-shirts, but any extra funds go to support local nonprofits. In 2019, $30,000 went to 21 groups including money for the parade, Movies in the Park, the Pacific Palisades Baseball Association, the Palisades-Malibu YMCA, local schools and the Village Green.) 

I want to thank Pacific Palisades residents, runners, kids and all the volunteers for helping with the Will Rogers 5 & 10K Run and Kids’ Fun Run.

For the last two years, Races #43 and #44 have been canceled. Last year it was cancelled because of the Covid-19 virus shutdown.

This year, we had to cancel because of the City’s unwillingness to issue a permit with unconditional restrictions until June 15.

I understand the reluctance to issue the 2021 permit for bureaucratic reasons, but there is too much to do in the short time allotted after June 15 in order to put on a 5/10K and Kids’ Fun Run that runners would be proud of and appreciate. Therefore, the 44th Race was canceled.

Residents can still help celebrate the 44th race by making a donation. Various local nonprofits need our support more than ever.

All donors of $20 or more can pick up a specially designed t-shirt, including Kids’ Fun Run t-shirts, which will be distributed with a family donation. T-shirt pick up details will be included with the donation receipt. (Visit: palisades10k.com)

Who knew 44 years ago that the Palisades Will Rogers Run would grow from humble beginnings to one of the Premier Races on the West Coast?

Thank you all for your past and future support.

Brian Shea

P.S., I’m looking forward to the 45th PWRR … Hopefully next year!!!

 

Posted in General | 1 Comment

OBITUARY: Gavin MacLeod, 90, Former Honorary Mayor and “The Love Boat” Captain

Gavin MacLeod, born February 29, 1931, in Mount Kisco, N.Y., passed away on May 29, at his home in Palm Desert. He was 90.

Gavin served as honorary mayor of Pacific Palisades for five years (2006 to 2011) at the invitation of the Chamber of Commerce. Arnie Wishnick, the Chamber’s executive director at the time, said that Gavin was one of his favorites. Often, when walking by the Chamber office on Antioch, one could see Wishnick and MacLeod deep in conversation.

Chamber assistant Marilyn Crawford told Circling the News, “Gavin and Steve Guttenberg were very special and took their positions seriously. In fact, they each served double terms and a bit longer—we just could not let them go.”

At the annual Chamber installation dinner, when MacLeod turned the gavel over to Sugar Ray Leonard, he said he was sad to leave Pacific Palisades and the position he had held longer than any of his predecessors.

“Gavin has been a superb mayor who was always there for us, when we asked him to attend a Chamber event,” Wishnick said. “But he and his wife have moved to the desert, so it’s time for a new mayor.”

MacLeod grew up in Pleasantville, New York. His mother worked for Reader’s Digest, while his father was an electrician who was part Chippewa. He attended Ithaca College, graduating in 1952. He served in the U.S. Air Force and then moved to New York and worked at Radio City Music Hall as an usher and elevator operator while seeking work as an actor, changing his name from Allan George See.

MacLeod made his screen debut in the 1958 Susan Hayward vehicle “I Want to Live.” He had a supporting role in Blake Edwards’ World War II comedy “Operation Petticoat,” starring Cary Grant and Tony Curtis.

Working steadily, he found a home on “McHale’s Navy” from 1962 to 1964, and then moved to “The Mary Tyler Moore Show.” He had originally tested for Moore’s TV boss, Lou Grant, the role that went to Ed Asner. MacLeod asked if he could try instead for the wisecracking TV news writer.

The “Moore” cast — MacLeod, Asner, Valerie Harper, Cloris Leachman, Betty White and Georgia Engel — reminisced with Moore in 2002 on CBS’ “The Mary Tyler Moore Reunion.” (Another important cast member, Ted Knight, was a Palisades honorary mayor from 1981 to 1983. He died in 1986.)

Asner, one of two surviving members of the cast, said Saturday that “My heart is broken. Gavin was my brother, my partner in crime (and food) and my comic conspirator. I will see you in a bit, Gavin. Tell the gang I will see them in a bit. Betty! It’s just you and me now.”

After playing the news writer on the “Moore” show, Gavin became the Captain on “The Love Boat,” a romantic comedy that although scorned by critics was adored by fans and ran for 11 seasons.

In his 2013 memoir, “This is Your Captain Speaking,” MacLeod acknowledged that he had struggled with alcoholism in the 1960s and 1970s. His father was an alcoholic.
He had four children with his first wife, Joan Rootvik. They were divorced in 1972.

MacLeod’s drinking problems helped lead to a second divorce, to actor-dancer Patti Steele. But after he quit drinking, he and Steele remarried in 1985 and became evangelicals. They credited religion for reuniting them. He wrote about this in his 1987 book, “Back on Course: The Remarkable Story of a Divorce That Ended in Remarriage.”

The couple hosted a Christian radio show called “Back on Course: A Ministry for Marriages.”

Besides his wife, MacLeod’s survivors include his children, three stepchildren, 10 grandchildren and his first great-grandchild, who arrived in December.

Posted in Obituaries | 3 Comments

Alan Eisenstock’s Playlist: Baby Songs

Editor’s note: When Palisadian Alan Eisenstock is not researching and writing one of his nonfiction books (18 thus far!), he pursues what he calls “a crazy labor of love side project” that he started in March 2020: sending a weekly Covid-themed playlist of songs to his family and friends. These playlists (which can be downloaded on Spotify Click here.) span rock ‘n’ roll and pop music from the 1950s to 2020, and Eisenstock adds one or two lines of commentary about each song that is clever, amusing and informative.)

 

Hi, Everyone,

Waaa! That’s the sound many news outlets predicted we’d hear constantly over the next two years. But the C.D.C. just released data indicating that the U.S. birthrate has dropped to the lowest level since 1979. What to do? Idea. Here are 23 “baby” songs! Listen up!

  1. “Isn’t She Lovely” Stevie Wonder. Born Stevland Morris, Stevie recorded this celebration of his daughter, Aisha Morris, in 1976, from his Songs in the Key of Lifealbum. That’s Aisha herself doing the baby sounds and gurgling.
  2. “Baby I Need Your Loving” Four Tops. Famous R&B vocal quartet from Detroit sings this 1964 Holland-Dozier-Holland composition. Originally, they called themselves The Four Aims.
  3. “Maybe Baby” Buddy Holly & The Crickets. Charles Hardin Holley renamed himself Buddy Holly, joined forces with The Crickets, and became one of the most influential singer-songwriters in the history of rock. Still stunning that he died in a plane crash at age 22.
  4. “Baby Love” The Supremes. Another Holland-Dozier-Holland composition and big hit from 1964. Diana Ross sings lead, Florence Ballard and Mary Wilson provide the “baby baby baby” backup. In case you hadn’t noticed, there are A LOT of “baby” songs.
  5. “Sweet Baby James” James Taylor. James writes and sings his signature song from his breakthrough album of the same name. He wrote the song for his brother’s son (that would be his nephew), also named James. It’s a good thing he didn’t write the song after his other brother’s son, Clem. “Sweet Baby Clem?” No.
  6. “Daughter” Loudon Wainwright III. Witty songwriter Wainwright, husband to folksinger Kate McGarrigle, father of Rufus and Martha, got divorced, had a relationship with singer Suzzy Roche and had a daughter. This song isn’t about any of these kids because Peter Blegvad wrote it, not Loudon. This was our “daughter-daddy” song at my daughter’s wedding. I’m currently verklempt.
  7. “B-A-B-Y” Carla Thomas. “The Queen of Memphis Soul” and daughter of soul singer Rufus Thomas sings this 1966 hit written by Isaac Hayes and David Porter.
  8. “A Father’s First Spring” The Avett Brothers. Scott Avett wrote this touching tribute to his daughter Eleanor after her birth in 2008. As I’ve said before, once we’re “open,” see this band live.
  9. “(You’re) Having My Baby” Paul Anka, Odia Coates. The I’m having my baby song. R&B singer Coates sings the perfect accompaniment. This song hit #1 in 1974. As a songwriter, Anka was an absolute hit machine.
  10. “There Goes My Baby” The Drifters. R&B group formed in New York City. Ben E. King co-wrote and sings lead on this 1959 smash hit and famous “baby” song. The other Drifters do well singing “Doo Doo” and “Bo WA” in the background.
  11. “Don’t Worry Baby” The Beach Boys. Legendary “baby” song written by Brian Wilson and Roger Christian, the B-side of “I Get Around.” Totally different sounds, but I’m partial to this. Best Brian Wilson rumor. He once filled his living room with sand to replicate a beach.
  12. “Be My Baby” The Ronettes. Originally from Spanish Harlem and naming themselves “The Darling Sisters,” this is an all-time great girl group led by Veronica Bennett. She later married Phil and became Ronnie Spector. Jeff Barry, Ellie Greenwich, and Phil Spector wrote this huge hit in 1959. One year, Phil surprised Ronnie with an unusual Christmas present: adopted twin sons.
  13. “Ooo Baby Baby” Smokey Robinson & The Miracles. Tremendous Motown group led by the man Bob Dylan called his favorite songwriter. Smokey and fellow Miracle Pete Moore wrote this lament in 1965.
  14. “Father And Daughter” Paul Simon. Paul wrote this song for the 2002 animated film The Wild Thornberrys Movie. He wrote it for his daughter Lulu, who was seven. His son Adrian, 10, sings backup. Another song that makes me verklempt.
  15. “Baby’s In Black” The Beatles. From the 1964 album Beatles For Sale. Not a “baby” song at all. “My baby’s in black and I’m feeling blue.” Felt the need for the Lads.
  16. “Baby, I’m Yours” Barbara Lewis. Michigan soul singer Lewis sings this 1965 hit written by Van McCoy. The song has found its way into several movies, including The Bridges of Madison County and Baby Driver.
  17. “Child Of Mine” Carole King. There I go. Losing it again. Verrrrklempt. This time it’s because of King’s 1970 song about her, yes, child. James Taylor sings backup and plays acoustic guitar.
  18. “Baby It’s You” The Shirelles. The New Jersey girl group led by Shirley Owens sings this 1962 Burt Bacharach, Luther Dixon, Mack David composition that became a big hit for them and later, The Beatles.
  19. “Hey! Baby” Bruce Channel. One-hit wonder Channel, from Jacksonville, Texas, is known for this huge 1962 number one hit with terrible punctuation. He also recorded “Mr. Bus Driver,” a song that for some reason I remember.
  20. “Father And Son” Yusaf/Cat Stevens. From 1970 and Tea For The Tillerman. Another one that gets to me. An emotional song about a troubled father-son relationship that Stevens sings as a duet–with himself. He sort of changes voices and it sort of works. Well, I’m crying.
  21. “Baby Now That I’ve Found You” The Foundations. British multiracial soul band sings this 1967 hit. Their follow-up hit was “Build Me Up, Buttercup.” They were considered the first British band to emulate the Motown sound.
  22. “Cry Baby” Garnet Mimms and The Enchanters. One of my favorite all-time band names. Garnet, from Philly, recorded this song in 1963. Janis Joplin recorded her bigger hit version in 1970, but I prefer the original.
  23. “I Got You Babe” Sonny & Cher. Husband and wife, pop duo, TV stars, and originally backup singers for Phil Spector. This is their biggest hit. They recorded their version in 1965, backed by L.A.’s famous session musicians, The Wrecking Crew.

And there we have it… 23 “baby” songs culled especially for you from about a million choices. Some advice:

Don’t Forget to Disinfect and… PLAY IT LOUD!

The link again: Click here.

Fact Check

James Taylor’s other brother does not have a son named Clem. I don’t know if he even has another brother.

I did hear that Brian Wilson filled his living room with sand to replicate a beach.

Phil Spector did surprise Ronnie with adopted twins for Christmas. Good present. My best? I once gave my wife a blender.

LAST WEEK’S POLL QUESTION:

In the “Teenager” face-off, “Teenager In Love” sped past “Teen Angel.”

THIS WEEK’S POLL QUESTION:

Favorite “Baby” song: “Baby, It’s You,” “Baby Love,” “There Goes My Baby” or other? Who you got?

 

Until next week,

Thanks,

Alan

alaneisenstock.com

Posted in Arts | 1 Comment

Design Review Board Favors Remodeling at 76 Station, Objects to Plans for The Shade Store

This was the proposed new façade for The Shade Store.

This was the storefront being replaced.

At its May 12th virtual meeting, the Pacific Palisades Design Review Board discussed plans for two buildings that residents will eventually notice.

The 76 Station, at the corner of Sunset and Via de la Paz (adjacent to Gelson’s), will expand its operations with a two-story building on the same footprint as its current building.

The service bay will be eliminated, and the ground floor will be turned into a convenience store. The second floor will be used for offices and storage for the convenience store.

Owner Robert Munakash said, “There will be no wine and beer. It will not be open 24 hours.”

When asked why he’s closing the service bay, he said, “My service is not as good for profitability.”

Munakash said one reason he was taking this action is because of his experience at his second location at PCH and Sunset, where he has a convenience store. “It’s been a game changer.”

Another reason for his decision was because Greg, his service manager, was ready to retire. Munakash added that the other service employees might be hired by the Shell station across the street (which will have the only surviving service bay in the business district).

“We’ll sell oil and washer fluid, but we just won’t do repairs and oil changes,” Munakash said. “I appreciate everyone’s business.”

The building design he presented was deemed “a pleasant looking building — you’re almost there,” by DRB members. They asked him to consider a different second-floor window and to present a landscaping plan.

The changes/design will come back for final approval at the next meeting.

Representatives from The Shade Store, a national chain, presented a dark-grey block building that would replace Robeks Juice (on Antioch across from the Village Green), featuring a patio, landscaping and several windows.

One DRB member commented, “I find [the proposed building] really cold and antithetical to the Palisades.”

Another member said that there is a continuity of the existing building and this design was “an abrupt change.”

The architect, Michael Busch, was asked if the design had been approved by the owner and he assured the DRB that it had been. He said the owner (Trust Commercial Property-Parotti) wants to update the existing building, with a new façade.

The DRB members emphasized that the proposed design is important because “you become the bellwether and others will follow.” They also noted that the building lies between the venerable Village Green and the historical mural painted on the CVS building.

“This building doesn’t really fit in,” a DRB member said. “It’s not the Palisades.”

The members all agreed that although the design had a classical elegant look, it didn’t fit – “It looks like inside a mall. It is a beautiful design, but for someplace else.”

The DRB asked the architect/owner to resubmit and also include a landscape plan.

The next meeting will be held virtually at 6:30 p.m. on June 9.

 

 

Posted in businesses/stores, Community | 4 Comments

A Letter in Response to “Do Not be Mean to My Husband”

Sean Arian with husband Councilman Mike Bonin

(Editor’s note: Today, in a Re-Elect Mike Bonin message, Councilman Mike Bonin’s husband Sean wrote: 

“I wanted to be sure you saw the Los Angeles Times editorial about my husband, Mike Bonin.

This past Sunday, the paper wrote about his efforts to confront the homelessness crisis, calling him “brave” and “enterprising” in confronting “the moral crisis of our time in this city.” That’s definitely the Mike I know.

I can tell you from personal experience, from the moment he wakes up until he falls asleep at night, Mike is fighting with passion and determination to get people out of encampments and into housing. His proposals to provide housing, shelter and services have been met with lawsuits, appeals, and personal, false and vitriolic attacks. We’ve had people chanting “evict the homeless from Los Angeles” and “White lives matter” outside our home in Mar Vista. . . .. 

I was proud to see the LA Times tell the truth about Mike, and I hope you can, too. You can share the editorial with your friends, and you can help Mike fight the negative attacks and the lies by donating to his re-election campaign.  

People who oppose solutions are lining up to come after Mike. I know that won’t slow him down, but he needs your help. Can you show him that we are in this together?”) 

One CTN reader in Pacific Palisades submitted this response:

Sean,

Thank you for your thoughts regarding your husband.

Unfortunately, the homeless problem is very difficult.

The City Council’s vote [to pursue a feasibility plan] to place homeless shelters on Will Rogers Beach is not a proper solution for getting homeless off the streets.

I suggest that the Mayor, the City Council, and the Board of Supervisors investigate this solution: Have all government agencies find all the vacant industrial properties in Los Angeles County and the City of Los Angeles, and make plans to rent or acquire these sites for potential homeless shelters. I am sure they exist in all Council Districts and throughout Los Angeles County. This would provide hundreds of locations to house the homeless.

If our City and County governments would consider this suggestion, we could avoid placing homeless on Will Rogers Beach which is owned by the State of California.

Please discuss this suggestion with your husband, because we, the taxpayers’ voices, are never heard.

I empathize with your husband with all the negative feedback he receives on the homeless problem, but we need realistic solutions that do not include Will Rogers State Beach.

Chuck McGlothlin

Posted in General | 9 Comments

Ready for Some Live Theater? PaliHi Students Offer a Musical Comedy This Weekend

This Friday and Saturday at 8 p.m., Palisades High School will present “First Date,” a musical comedy, on the Quad. There will be a live band.

To reserve a ticket go to palihighasb.square.site/. Attendees will be required to acknowledge they have no Covid-19 symptoms and have a temperature check before being allowed on campus.

A parent who alerted Circling the News about the event wrote: “It came together quickly, and the kids have been working incredibly hard. After the cancellation of last year’s Spring Musical, it is especially wonderful that the seniors will have this opportunity to perform one last time at Pali. The show will be performed in the Quad, so it will be a rare opportunity to watch a Pali High performance under the stars.”

And folks, it is a comedy. We all need an evening of laughter.

“First Date” was written by Austin Winsberg, with music and lyrics by Alan Zachary and Michael Weiner. It had its premiere in Seattle in 2012 and made its Broadway debut in 2013.

The show starts with five New Yorkers sharing their dating disasters and then transitions to a blind date in a restaurant as an “artsy” woman Casey looks for the man she’s supposed to be meeting, a quirky Aaron.

While they are on the date, their friends and families pop up in the couple’s thoughts offering advice. For example, Casey initially wants to order a burger, but her sister tells her it will give the impression that years from now she will be overweight, so she orders a salad instead. Aaron, on the other hand, wants a salad, but his best friend tells him that “salads are for wussies,” so he orders a burger.

This sounds like it will be a delightful, light evening, especially knowing that PaliHi’s Cheri Smith is directing. No matter what show she has tackled in recent years, including “Chicago,” “Spring Awakening” and “The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time,” the production quality has been top-notch.

When CTN reviewed “Footloose” in 2018, we wrote: “A huge acknowledgement goes to the directors and choreographers, sisters Cheri and Monique Smith, for taking this huge group of kids, some of whom had never been on stage before, and turning this into an amazing show.’

 

Posted in Reviews, Schools | Leave a comment

National Poppy Day Is May 28

This year, National Poppy Day is May 28. On that day, Americans are asked to remember the sacrifices made by veterans while they were protecting our freedoms.

American Legion Auxiliaries across the nation pass out little red paper poppies in May as a symbol of remembrance and hope for a peaceful future. They are worn in a buttonhole or on a label as a show of support for the Armed Forces.

The red crepe paper poppies are handmade by veterans as part of their therapeutic rehabilitation and distributed in the community. The flowers were adopted by the National American Legion as an official symbol in 1920.

In the past Ronald Reagan Post 283 Auxiliary members have offered them up at the farmers market, CVS or other locations in Pacific Palisades exchange for donations that go directly to assist disabled and hospitalized veterans. Covid-19 has made distribution more difficult this year.

The idea for the paper poppies is traced back to Moina Michael, who after World War I read the poem “In Flanders Fields,” written by Canadian physician Lt. Col. McCrae. These small flowers were the first to grow in the soil from soldiers’ graves in the Flanders region of Belgium.

Please share the poem and the history of poppies with your children to help honor veterans and their efforts to preserve freedom.

 

Posted in General | 1 Comment

City Council Votes 13 to 1 to Pursue Homeless Feasibility Study

 

The L.A. City Council voted today to approve a motion by Councilmen Mike Bonin and Mark Ridley-Thomas (Motion 21-0350) to study the feasibility of using Will Rogers State Beach, Dockweiler Beach, LAX land and two city parks, Mar Vista and Westchester, as sites to house the homeless.

Initially, there was to be no public comment at the hearing (via Zoom), but an overwhelming number of residents contacted City Council President Nury Martinez requesting the opportunity to speak.

Martinez relented, and after nearly two hours of public comment (most of it fiercely opposed to the motion), only Councilman Joe Buscaino voted against the study.

Councilman Mitch O’Farrell pointed out to Councilmembers that Los Angeles is “park poor” and ranks 74th out of 100 large cities in terms of park space. That study found there were 6.8 acres of parkland for 1,000 residents in cities where there were more parks; in Los Angeles, it is only one acre per 1,000 people.

Many people in Los Angeles can “only access these sites [beaches] by car,” O’Farrell said, noting that for many poor families the beaches and parks are a vital respite. “Shared public spaces are in short supply and sacred.”

He continued, “We need to be mindful of decisions even for temporary solutions.” The proposal states that this would be a temporary solution but doesn’t list a timeline or subsequent steps that would revert beaches and parks to the public.

Before voting, O’Farrell asked for clarification that this motion was strictly about the feasibility study and not in favor of the idea. He was assured that this was correct.

The feasibility study will be paid for by taxpayers.

Buscaino said, “I’ll save time — these sites are not feasible.”

He spoke about three generations of a family living in an apartment in his district and “it’s not fair to deprive these people of parks and beaches. Public spaces belong to all of us.”

Bonin defended his proposal by saying “I am determined that my part of town should do its part [in dealing with the homeless].”

Martinez said that her office had received 550 calls and 100 voicemails about the subject. “I understand the public’s frustration with this issue. We’ve taxed them, but we haven’t lived up to our end of the bargain. We need to clean and manage our public streets.”

Twenty-year Playa Del Rey resident Lucy Han spoke. “This motion will decrease access to Dockweiler Beach and seems to target and discriminate against low-income people of color. Many families who frequent Dockweiler Beach come from the southern LA region and oftentimes are large low-income communities made up of persons of color. Council Districts 8, 9 & 15 are most affected. Residents drive on the 105 Freeway to their nearest beach which is Dockweiler. This proposal would reduce accessibility to Dockweiler Beach by eliminating parking spots, affecting literally thousands of people, daily.”

Suddenly her call was dropped. CTN later contacted Han, who said, “They cut me off. I called back and was waiting to speak, and they closed public comment.”

CTN asked for the rest of her comment, which she supplied.

“In 2017, Councilman Bonin’s Road Diet reduced accessibility to Dockweiler Beach by eliminating 400 parking spaces on Vista Del Mar. Please do not allow his efforts to again prevent beach access to this marginalized segment of our community. Dockweiler Lot #3 is the one targeted and it has 418 spots.

“Bonin admitted that he is not in a position to increase enforcement or increase services,” Han said. “He says that’s LAPD’s and County’s jurisdiction.

The homeless encampments in Venice have sprung up around bridge housing.

“Residents are livid about Bonin’s Bridge Housing in Venice. Bonin promised LAPD would secure a safe zone around the shelter,” Han said. “There is no LAPD as promised. Bridge Housing has attracted encampments to the shelter. The numbers have increased. Crime has skyrocketed.

“Bonin promised to provide significant sanitation services to clean up. Instead, Bonin allowed the homeless to refuse City clean ups. Bridge residents do not abide by the rules. They are frequently using drugs in the communal spaces. When residents get in fights, LAPD is not called. The residents are kicked out so that no crime is reported against the shelter, thus improving the success metrics of Bridges.

“How can we trust Bonin if he won’t make good on his promises to Venice? Why would we allow him to move his homeless shelters into our community? There are many underutilized City properties that should be considered, NOT our parks and beaches.

“Over 35,000 people have signed our petitions against this motion. Over 1,000 pages of letters are recorded in the Council File. Six Neighborhood Councils & two Community Councils oppose the motion.

“We ALL want to help the unhoused, but we need a proven, well-thought out and holistic solution,” Han concluded.

Palisades residents also chimed in. “Nothing could be more WRONG than creating a homeless encampment — tiny homes or otherwise — on a parking lot at Will Rogers State Beach and other beachside or park locations,” said one. “Doing so not only removes parking space for visitors from all over. What does it do to the overall recreation area that is used by so many who want and need to escape the heat, density and worries of our more urban neighborhoods?”

Another resident said, “Please do not even consider allowing tiny homes or other living spaces to be placed on a beach parking lot, such as our treasured Will Rogers State Beach. This beach and the parking lots that serve the beach are for recreation. (By the way, what would these people do during the day? Will they leave the ‘compound’ and walk just a few blocks to hang around Canyon Elementary School?)”

Yet another resident sent a video that was recorded today. “Here is a good reason why homeless people should not be living near PCH . . .911 was called on this mentally ill man. He crossed in traffic multiple times and almost was hit. At the meeting held by the Pacific Palisades Task Force on Homelessness, Dr. Jonathan Sherin, L.A. County Director of Mental Health, said this is one of the top reasons homeless are dying.”

Jessica Rogers, president of the Pacific Palisades Residents Association also spoke at the meeting. “We need to build shelters for the mentally ill. Focus on the real issue please.”

Several advocates for the homeless supported Bonin’s motion and went after residents on the Westside, calling them “these people … they want to keep their million-dollar mansions free of poor people.”

Stacy Shure (Mar Vista Neighborhood Council Zone 1 Director and Planning and Land Use Chair) said,  “We need long-term housing; we do not need to move the homeless around like Legos on a board.

“Mar Vista has little open space. The need has never been greater for open spaces, especially for the impoverished who do not have access to open space.

“Stop creating temporary solutions. Stop trying to divide us.”

This homeless encampment was across from Mar Vista Park.

Posted in City/Councilman Mike Bonin, Councilman Mike Bonin, Crime/Police, Homelessness | 1 Comment